Why is Scottish Tax different than UK tax?

Scottish taxpayers have different income tax than the rest of the UK. Since April 2016 the Scottish government has been abelt to set their own rate for Income Tax due to the “Scotland Act 2012”. These rates differ from the rest of the UK, however, standard UK tax rates still apply to savings and divident income.

The Scottish rate of income (SRIT) is payable on the non-savings and non-dividend income of those defined as Scottish taxpayers. This means that Scottish taxpayers who also have savings and dividend income need to consider the UK rates as well as the Scottish rates when calculating their income tax bill.

Scottish taxpayer status applies for a whole tax year. It is not possible to be a Scottish taxpayer for part of a tax year. The definition of a Scottish taxpayer is generally focused on the question of whether the taxpayer has a ‘close connection’ with Scotland or elsewhere in the UK. The idea of being treated as a Scottish taxpayer is not based on nationalist identity, location of work or the source of a person’s income e.g., receiving a salary from a Scottish business.

For the vast majority of individuals, the question of whether or not they are defined as a Scottish taxpayer is a simple one – they either live in Scotland and are a Scottish taxpayer or live elsewhere in the UK and are not a Scottish taxpayer.

More specifically, an individual will generally be defined a Scottish taxpayer if they satisfy any of the following tests:

1. They are a Scottish Parliamentarian.
2. They have a ‘close connection’ to Scotland, through either:
   i) having only a single ‘place of residence’, which is in Scotland; or
   ii) where they have more than one ‘place of residence’, having their ‘main place of residence’ in Scotland for at least as much of the tax year as it has been in any one other part of the UK.
3. Where no ‘close connection’ to Scotland (or any other part of the UK) exists (either through it not being possible to identify any place of residence or a main residence) – then place of residence will be decided by day counting.

There will always be cases where a taxpayer’s status is not so clear cut. HMRC’s technical guidance looks at relevant case law and includes examples where a taxpayer has more than one residence either side of the border.

What If HMRC Gets It Wrong?

Scottish taxpayer status is determined by HMRC based on your main place of residence. In most cases, this works correctly. However, errors can occur — particularly if you move address and HMRC records are not updated promptly.

Potential Risks

• Overpayment of tax if Scottish rates are applied incorrectly.
• Underpayment of tax if you should be taxed under Scottish rates but are not.
• End-of-year adjustments through PAYE reconciliation.

An incorrect status does not normally create penalties by itself, but it may result in a tax underpayment that HMRC later seeks to recover.

Correcting an Incorrect Tax Code

If you believe your status is wrong:

• Check whether your tax code includes an “S” prefix (for Scottish taxpayers).
• Confirm that HMRC holds your correct current address.
• Contact HMRC directly to request a review if your residency details are incorrect.

Once updated, HMRC will normally issue a revised tax code to your employer.

End-of-Year Reconciliation

If the wrong rates have been applied during the tax year, HMRC may correct this through:

• A P800 tax calculation, or
• An adjustment to your following year’s tax code.

Reviewing your PAYE coding notice and year-end position helps prevent surprises.

What Happens If You Move During the Tax Year?

Moving between Scotland and the rest of the UK can create confusion about which tax rates apply. Scottish taxpayer status is based on where your main place of residence is during the tax year.

Moving from England to Scotland

• If your main residence becomes Scotland, you may be treated as a Scottish taxpayer for that tax year.
• HMRC will normally update your tax code to include the “S” prefix.

Moving from Scotland to England

• If your main residence moves outside Scotland, Scottish rates may no longer apply.
• Your tax code may revert to a standard UK code without the “S” prefix.

How “Main Place of Residence” Is Determined

Where more than one property is involved, HMRC considers:

• Where you spend the majority of your time.
• Where your family lives (if applicable).
• Where your personal and economic ties are strongest.

Scottish taxpayer status applies for the entire tax year, not proportionally based on the number of months spent in each location. This makes early notification of address changes important.

How to Check If You’re Registered as a Scottish Taxpayer

If you are unsure of your status, there are simple steps you can take.

1. Check Your Tax Code

• An “S” prefix at the start of your tax code indicates Scottish taxpayer status (for example, S1257L).
• No “S” prefix usually means standard UK income tax rates apply.

2. Review Your Personal Tax Account

You can log into your HMRC Personal Tax Account to confirm:

• Your recorded address.
• Your current tax code.
• Any recent changes to your PAYE coding.

3. Contact HMRC if Details Are Incorrect

If your address or residency details are wrong, you should notify HMRC as soon as possible. Once corrected, HMRC will issue an updated tax code to your employer.

Checking early reduces the likelihood of overpayments, underpayments, or year-end adjustments.