Losing Private Residence Relief: Key Events That Cause Partial or No Exemption Explained

Losing Private Residence Relief (PRR) happens mainly when a property is no longer used as the owner’s main home. Partial or no exemption occurs if part of the property is rented out, used exclusively for business, or if the owner moves out and the home becomes a second property. These situations reduce the relief and may lead to a capital gains tax bill.

Periods when the property is unoccupied or used for other purposes can also limit the relief. However, some rules protect the owner, such as allowing relief during certain absence periods or where only part of the property is used for business. Understanding these triggers is key to knowing why someone might lose some or all of their exemption.

Owners should be aware of how their property’s use affects PRR to avoid unexpected tax charges. This article looks closely at what causes partial or full loss of the relief and what steps might help reduce the impact. For official guidance, see this Private Residence Relief Helpsheet.

Understanding Private Residence Relief

Private Residence Relief (PRR) helps reduce or remove Capital Gains Tax (CGT) on the sale of a home that qualifies as a person’s main or principal private residence. Eligibility depends on the property meeting specific conditions, and some terms define how this relief is calculated and applied.

Definition and Scope

Private Residence Relief is a tax relief offered by HMRC that exempts the gain made when selling a property that has been the owner’s principal private residence. This means the property must be the person’s only or main home at some point during their ownership.

If a property has been partly used for business or let out, relief is usually limited. PRR only applies to gains related to the period when the house was the main residence. It does not cover gains related to times when the property was not used as a home.

PRR can result in zero CGT payable when selling a qualifying home. If only part of the property qualifies, partial relief applies.

Criteria for Eligibility

To qualify for Private Residence Relief:

• The property must have been the individual’s main residence during ownership.
• The owner must have lived in the property as their only or principal home.
• The relief covers the time the property was the main home, plus an additional period (usually the last 9 months before sale).
• If the property was let out or used for business, relief applies only to the time it was the residence, not for other uses without special conditions.

HMRC sets specific rules on how long someone must have lived in the property to claim PRR and how periods of absence are treated.

Key Terms and Concepts

Understanding these key terms helps clarify how PRR is applied and when an individual can expect relief from CGT on the sale of their home.

Full Exemption Versus Partial or No Exemption

Losing Private Residence Relief (PRR) affects how much capital gains tax (CGT) a person pays when selling a home. Full exemption means no CGT is payable on the chargeable gain. Partial or no exemption increases the taxable gain, which could lead to CGT due beyond the annual exemption threshold.

Conditions for Full Exemption

Full exemption applies when the property was the person’s only or main residence throughout the entire ownership period. The exemption covers all the chargeable gain made when selling the home.

The owner must have lived in the property as their main home for the whole time and not rented it out or used it for business purposes. HMRC recognises this usage as qualifying for PRR automatically, meaning no capital gains tax will be due.

Periods of absence may be allowed if they meet specific criteria, such as moving for work or temporary absence, but these must be short and limited. Full exemption removes any taxable gain, no matter how large.

Scenarios Leading to Partial Relief

Partial relief arises when the owner lived in the property for only part of the time they owned it. This happens if the home was rented out, used for business, or left empty for some periods.

HMRC calculates relief by apportioning the gain according to the time the property was the main residence. Some final periods, like the last nine months of ownership, usually qualify for exemption too, even if not lived in then.

If the property was used partly for business or rented, the owner faces a taxable gain on the portion linked to non-residential use. This taxable gain is subject to CGT after the annual exemption applies.

Triggers for No Exemption

No exemption occurs if the home was never the person’s main residence. This may apply if they always rented or used it solely for business.

HMRC requires proof that the property was the main home to grant PRR. If no evidence of residence exists, the entire gain becomes a taxable gain.

Another trigger is failure to meet relief conditions, such as long letting without residence or certain business use periods. In these cases, the owner must pay CGT on the full chargeable gain minus the annual exemption.

Common Triggers for Losing Relief

Certain actions or changes can reduce or remove Private Residence Relief (PRR), affecting how much Capital Gains Tax is owed when selling a home. These triggers often relate to how the property is used or if it stops being the main residence for a period.

Change of Main Residence

If a person moves out and makes another property their main home, the original home may lose full PRR. Relief is usually only granted on the time a property was the main residence, plus the last 9 months of ownership.

For example, if someone moves from a marital home to a second home or a new property after divorce, the original residence no longer qualifies for full relief. This can result in partial PRR based on the months it was lived in.

Switching main residences often causes a reduction in relief available, especially if both homes overlap in use or if the first home is rented out. It is important to keep precise records of all residence periods.

Periods of Absence

Time spent away from the home without it being a main residence can reduce PRR. Some absences may qualify for relief, such as temporary work abroad or certain permitted absences.

However, longer absences when the property is not the main home, or when the homeowner has no other residence, will trigger partial relief only. The relief includes the final 9 months of ownership regardless of occupation.

Periods of absence can be tracked carefully to claim maximum relief, but extensive time away without living in the house means more gain becomes taxable.

Business or Letting Use

Using the property for business purposes or renting it out can stop or reduce PRR, depending on the time and extent of such use.

If part or all of the home is used as a business base, or if it is rented as residential accommodation, the relief may be lost for those periods. Lettings relief might apply but only under strict conditions and with limits.

When the house is split between living space and business or rental, the gain is apportioned. Complete change to business or rental use usually means PRR does not apply for that time, increasing the tax charge.

Understanding the impact of business or letting use helps avoid unexpected capital gains costs. Refer to detailed guidance to calculate relief accurately.

Special Situations Impacting Exemption

Certain events can affect Private Residence Relief (PRR) and reduce or remove the exemption on capital gains tax. These include changes involving marital status, inheritance matters, and the way property or land is sold.

Matrimonial Home and Divorce

When a couple divorces or separates, the exemption may change. The matrimonial home often qualifies for full PRR while it is the main residence. However, if one partner moves out and the property is rented or left empty, relief may be reduced.

If the property is transferred between spouses during divorce, no immediate tax charge occurs, but later sales by either party will consider the time they lived there for calculating PRR. Delays in selling the former marital home can also limit relief, especially if it isn’t the owner’s main home anymore.

Inheritance and Probate Value

When a property is inherited, its value is set at probate for tax purposes. PRR usually does not apply to the period before inheritance, as the property wasn’t the owner’s main residence.

After inheritance, if the beneficiary uses the property as their main home, they may claim PRR for the period they live there. However, gains accrued before inheritance are often subject to different rules. Understanding how probate value influences capital gains calculations is important in planning any future sale.

Sales of Part Land or Multiple Dwellings

Selling only part of a property’s land or when a property has multiple dwellings can affect PRR. Relief applies only to the portion used as the main home.

For example, if there is a large garden or an outbuilding sold separately, any gain attributed to that land may not qualify for relief. Similarly, where a dwelling includes several units, PRR is calculated based on the part actually occupied.

It is important to clearly identify and value the main home portion to apply PRR correctly.

Calculating the Taxable Gain on Disposal

When a property no longer qualifies for full Private Residence Relief, the taxable gain must be carefully worked out. This involves assessing the market value, identifying the chargeable asset, considering any reliefs like rollover relief, and understanding how Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) affects the calculation.

Market Value and Chargeable Assets

The taxable gain is usually the difference between the sale price and the original purchase price, after deducting allowable costs. However, if a property is sold at a lower price to a connected person or transferred in certain circumstances, HMRC may require the use of the market value instead of the actual price.

The chargeable asset is the property or part of it that is liable for Capital Gains Tax (CGT). If only part of the home was used for business or rented out, that section’s gain may be taxed. The owner must clearly separate personal residence periods from times when the property was let or used commercially to calculate the gain precisely.

Rollover Relief Interaction

Rollover relief can postpone the CGT when the proceeds from selling a business asset, including some parts of a residential property used for business, are reinvested in another qualifying asset.

If rollover relief applies, the gain is not immediately taxable. Instead, it reduces the cost basis of the new asset. This means the taxable gain calculation for the previous property depends on whether the reinvestment is completed within a set time frame, normally within three years.

Consideration of Stamp Duty Land Tax

Stamp Duty Land Tax paid when acquiring a property can impact the taxable gain. SDLT forms part of the cost base, effectively reducing the gain when the property is sold.

It is important to include the SDLT paid as part of the acquisition costs because it increases the overall amount deducted from the sale proceeds. Failing to include SDLT can lead to overstating the taxable gain, resulting in higher CGT.

Records of SDLT must be kept as proof when submitting the tax calculation to HMRC.

Resolving Disputes and Appeals with HMRC

When disputes arise over Private Residence Relief, it is vital to understand the appeal process and how to present evidence effectively. Knowing which bodies handle disputes and how to communicate with HMRC increases the chance of a fair outcome.

First-tier Tribunal Role

The First-tier Tribunal is the main body where appeals against HMRC decisions are heard. It deals with disputes about tax reliefs, including Private Residence Relief.

The tribunal reviews all evidence from both HMRC and the taxpayer. It offers an independent and legally binding decision. If the appellant disagrees with the outcome, they may appeal further to the Upper Tribunal, but only on points of law.

The appeal to the tribunal must usually be filed within 30 days of HMRC’s decision notice. Missing this timeframe can result in losing the right to challenge the decision.

Evidence and Documentation

Clear and organised evidence is essential when contesting Private Residence Relief decisions. Taxpayers should gather:

• Purchase and sale documents
• Residency records and dates
• Correspondence with HMRC
• Financial statements showing any capital improvements

Accurate records prove the property’s main use and help identify if relief applies partially or fully. Without solid evidence, appeals risk rejection.

Keeping copies of all submitted documents and notes on conversations with HMRC supports the case during hearings or reviews.

Working with HMRC

Effective communication with HMRC can resolve disputes before they reach the tribunal. Taxpayers should respond promptly to HMRC queries and provide requested information clearly.

If dissatisfied, a formal written appeal must explain the reasons for disagreement and include any supporting evidence. HMRC usually reviews these appeals internally.

Taxpayers can ask for clarification or guidance during this stage to avoid filing incorrect appeals. Persistence and professionalism improve chances of a satisfactory resolution without costly tribunal proceedings.

For more detail on appealing HMRC decisions, see appealing a tax decision.

Reliable Accounting Support with Cigma Accounting: Based in Wimbledon, our accountants are committed to supporting your business’s financial health. We offer dependable payroll services near you, comprehensive corporation tax accounting, and meticulous VAT accounting. Trust us to manage your accounting needs so you can focus on what you do best. Reach out today to schedule a consultation.